March 7, 2026
Islip saw 12 pending home sales in January 2026 at a median listing price of $614,450, down 10.8% year-over-year. With 41 active listings, buyers have more options near East Islip's hot $1.4M market.
As Long Island's housing market heats up with East Islip's St. Patrick's Parade planning underway, Islip's January 2026 home sales show stability with **12 pending sales** at a median listing price of **$614,450**, down 10.8% from $688,500 last year.
Islip recorded **12 pending sales** from **41 active listings**, up 20.6% in inventory from 34 last year, giving buyers near Main Street and Montauk Highway more choices. Homes average **100 days on market**, with high demand at 73% versus 27% supply. Nearby East Islip bucked the trend, selling 4 homes at a median **$1.4M**, up 111% year-over-year, in **22 days**.
Islip's median listing dipped to **$614,450** (-10.8% YoY), while average price hit **$786,310** (-19.6% YoY). Zillow pegs typical Islip home values at **$641,693**, up 2.1% over the past year. Central Islip listings medianed **$549,999**, signaling a seller's market. Population of 13,501 with median income **$114,185** fuels steady interest.
East Islip homes sell **3% above list** on average, pending in **26 days**, amid Suffolk's competitive scene. Builders note improving rates boosting demand, though buyer confidence lags. Check listings on Montauk Highway or near Islip's Redefine Meals expansion site for opportunities.
Stay ahead of Long Island's real estate shifts—explore more LI Daily market data and connect with local agents today. For a broader look at how Central Islip's $65M revamp is reshaping the area, see our latest development coverage, and track how Suffolk County's planning initiatives continue to influence local housing trends.
