March 8, 2026
Smithtown home sales hit 15 in January 2026, down from 26 last year, but median prices jumped 12.1% to $827K. Suffolk buyers face hot competition on streets like Main Street.
Smithtown home sales stats show a competitive Suffolk County market in January 2026, with median prices hitting $827K, up 12.1% from last year. Homes sold after just 19 days on average, faster than the prior 26 days, amid Suffolk's ongoing demand near spots like Kings Park Bluff and Main Street in Smithtown.
In Smithtown, part of Suffolk County, 15 homes sold in January 2026, down from 26 the year before. Yet the median sale price soared to $827K, with price per square foot at $441, up 19.8% year-over-year. This reflects strong buyer interest in family homes along Route 25 and neighborhoods like The Landing.
Active listings reached 61 in Smithtown, with 47 closed sales and 55 pending in recent data. Homes often sell 3% above list price, going pending in 22 days, and hot properties fetch 10% over in 11 days. Zillow pegs average home values at $785,481, up 5.7% yearly, signaling brisk action for sellers in zip 11787.
Realtor.com notes 90 homes for sale in 11787 at median list $850K, with days on market at 49. Month-over-month, listings rose 10.59%, but year-over-year counts fell 5.88%. Focus on three-bedroom single-family homes for quickest turnover near local gems like Smithtown Historical Society.
Suffolk County's Smithtown market stays hot—check LI Daily for updated real estate data, listings on Main Street, and tips to buy or sell now. For more on how nearby communities are trending, see Port Jefferson home prices climb to $894K median amid tight Suffolk inventory, and explore how Huntington Station home prices surge to $682K median across the region. Buyers interested in new development opportunities can also follow the Beechwood Country Pointe Estates project advancing in Kings Park just next door.
