March 4, 2026
Discover Babylon's top pizza spots, from Mulberry Street's local gem to The Pizzeria's spicy hot honey squares. These Village favorites deliver classic slices and unique pies perfect for Long Island nights.
With Long Island's South Shore buzzing from recent waterfront events in nearby Fire Island Pines, Babylon Village locals are craving comfort food like never before. And nothing hits the spot quite like a hot slice of pizza from one of these top Babylon pizzerias. Whether you're strolling Deer Park Avenue or grabbing takeout near the LIRR station, these spots serve up the best pizza in Babylon, blending classic New York style with fresh twists.
Mulberry Street Babylon tops the list as the go-to pizza spot in Babylon Village. Located right in the heart of the village, this Italian and pizza joint earns rave reviews for its amazing pizza. Tripadvisor ranks it #1 among Babylon pizza places with a solid 4.2 out of 5 from 72 reviews, calling it a local favorite. Diners love the fresh pies that pair perfectly with pasta and pesto options on the menu. It's mid-range pricing ($$-$$$) makes it ideal for families or casual nights out. Open for delivery via Uber Eats as Mulberry St, it's easy to order ahead after a day exploring Babylon's shops on Main Street. Pro tip: Pair your pizza with their salad for a full Village meal. No trip to Babylon is complete without stopping here.
At #2, Molto Vino on 45 Deer Park Ave stands out for its perfect pizzas in a cute, quaint setting. This spot scores 4.5 out of 5 on Tripadvisor from 25 reviews, with fans calling it absolutely the best and perfect for date nights. As a Slice partner since 2021, they offer reliable curbside pickup and credit card payments for hot, fresh pizza to go. Their famous Marinara Pizza draws crowds, blending simple ingredients into Babylon's best dishes. Order online via their site or Slice Life for quick delivery near the Deer Park area. It's a popular independent pizzeria focusing on quality that keeps locals coming back. Swing by after errands for a slice that captures Long Island's pizza soul.
The Pizzeria at 217 E Main St in Babylon brings bold flavors with its square pies, especially the hot honey squares. This spot shines with options like cup & char pepperoni hot honey basil on Sicilian crust, plus burrata-topped pies drizzled in hot honey. Their 18-inch round pies feature fresh mozzarella, vodka sauce, and unique combos like buffalo chicken or balsamic bruschetta. With a full bar and diverse menu including pasta like short rib mac & cheese, it's more than just pizza. Call (631) 314-4500 to order ahead for pickup. Located on bustling East Main Street, it's perfect for Village walks. These hot honey squares are a must-try for anyone seeking spicy, modern twists on grandma-style crusts.
Francesco Pizzeria ranks high with a 3.8 out of 5 from 64 Tripadvisor reviews, offering Italian dishes beyond pizza. Customers rave about fresh, hot pies and wine pairings, calling it an upscale pizzeria extraordinaire. Their menu caters to dine-in or catering for events, with professional service in the dining room. Yelp fans like Molly M. highlight it as a cheat-night spot with no regrets, praising the delicious food. Mid-range ($$-$$$) and open for takeout, it's a solid choice near Babylon's core. Add pasta or other Italian options for a full meal that elevates your pizza night.
Rounding out the top 5, Cafe IL Villaggio delivers with 4.1 out of 5 from 53 reviews on Tripadvisor. Known for dishes like veal with eggplant and chicken parm alongside pizza, it's a renamed gem in Babylon. Mid-range pricing ($$-$$$) suits groups or families, with options for pasta in cream sauce. It's closed now but perfect for future visits, offering that classic Long Island Italian comfort. Great for large groups or special occasions in the Village setting.
Babylon's pizza scene thrives with these real-deal spots, from Mulberry Street's village charm to The Pizzeria's hot honey innovation. Next time you're in town, grab a slice and taste why locals swear by them. Check out more Long Island food guides on LI Daily to fuel your next adventure. If you're exploring more of the South Shore dining scene, don't miss the best new restaurants opening on Long Island this spring, or find out what else is happening in Babylon Village beyond the plate.
