March 9, 2026
Discover Port Jefferson's top pizza spots from coal-fired Neapolitan at The Pie to old-school slices at Colosseo. This guide covers must-try pies on Main Street and Route 112.
As the ferry horns echo across Long Island Sound from the Port Jefferson marina, locals and visitors alike crave a slice that hits just right after a day exploring the village. Best pizza in Port Jefferson means thin, crispy coal-fired pies, hearty old-school classics, and crowd-pleasing favorites right here on the North Shore.
Port Jefferson buzzes with Italian spots serving everything from Margherita masterpieces to Sicilian squares. Whether you're strolling Main Street or grabbing takeout near the harbor, these pizzerias deliver fresh, hand-crafted pies with that authentic Long Island flavor. We've rounded up the standouts based on local buzz, menus, and reviews from spots like Tripadvisor and Slice. Let's dive into the categories that make PJ pizza legendary.
Head to the heart of Main Street in Port Jefferson Village, and you'll find The Pie of Port Jeff at the center of the action, just a short walk from the marina. This family-friendly spot claims to be one of the few on Long Island serving true authentic coal-fired Neapolitan pizza—and the only place with this unique style. Their hand-crafted pies come thin, crispy, and well-done, baked in a real brick oven for that smoky char and rich flavor.
Locals rave about the Margherita pie, packed with fresh ingredients that make it a standout. Reviews call it "real brick oven pizza" with exceptional service and a cozy atmosphere perfect for couples or families. Beyond pizza, grab appetizers, fresh salads, homemade pastas, and desserts. In summer, it's the hottest spot when the village jumps; in winter, it's your go-to cozy hangout. They offer takeout, catering for parties, graduations, and corporate events, plus reliable delivery through platforms like Slice.
Customers love the beautiful decor and courteous staff. One reviewer said, "Pizza is a gift from God, it's definitely has a rich flavor especially with the margaritas pie." With a huge dine-in space, kid-friendly amenities, and fast delivery, The Pie nails the Neapolitan game in Port Jefferson.
For that no-frills, old-school pizza joint vibe, drive over to Colosseo Pizza at 1049 NY-112 in Port Jefferson Station. This strip mall staple has been doling out traditional pies and salads for decades, earning raves as potentially the best pizza on Long Island.
Reviewers who've been coming for years say nothing in Florida—or anywhere else—compares to the taste and quality. Pete G. shared, "Have been coming here for decades... When we visit we always stop here for a few slices." Tripadvisor users call it the best in Suffolk County, praising pepperoni slices, salads, and Sicilian pies. One recent fan noted, "Excellent Sicilian Pizza! ... We keep going back—it's now our favorite pizza place."
The efficient staff offers prompt service at attractive prices in a cozy atmosphere. Go for the Grandma pie or classic pepperoni—crispy edges and all. It's vegetarian-friendly, open for lunch, dinner, and late night, with cash-only vibes that keep it authentic. Perfect for families or quick bites near Terryville Road.
On 124 Main St, Port Jeff Pizza serves up crowd-pleasers like cheese pizza for $18.50 and Sicilian for $22. Their specialty lineup shines with the Famous Bacon Chicken Ranch at $25, plus Chicken Parmigiana, BBQ Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, and Meat Lovers for $23.50. Don't skip sides like garlic knots for $5.50 or rice balls at $4—deep-fried rice and cheese perfection.
They rate 4.9 on Slice with $2 delivery, making it a top pick for takeout. Greek specialties like chicken gyros for $10.75 add variety, alongside baked ziti and lasagna at $9 each.
Meanwhile, Joey Z's Brooklyn Pizza at 217 Main St brings Brooklyn-style thin-crust with a golden-brown crunch. Rated 4.6 on Slice, it's famed for pesto cauliflower, deep-dish, and reliable takeout. This Mediterranean spot expands to Greek, Italian, seafood, pasta, and fondue, with wheelchair access and kid-friendly options. Casual comfort foods make it a local go-to.
These spots highlight why Port Jefferson pizza scenes thrives—diverse styles from coal-fired to classics, all hyper-local and fresh.
Next time you're in Port Jefferson, slice into these favorites and taste the North Shore difference. Check out more LI Daily guides for the best eats across Long Island—your next meal awaits! And if you're exploring beyond pizza, don't miss our top pizza picks in Babylon for even more Long Island slice inspiration.
